It is a foregone conclusion that the dynamic of rostering athletic teams in college at the Division 1 level will dramatically change in 2025. The likely impact will hit hardest with football and basketball (M/W) and in the “Power 4” Conferences(ACC, BIG10, SEC, BIG12). The concept of a “scholarship” will be re-defined, roster limits may change, walk-on opportunities may end, and relative player value may vary from conference-to-conference, sport-to-sport, and position-to-position.
Regardless of the fine details to be ironed out as court settlements are approved, NCAA &institutional policies change, and with proposed legislation, one bit of advice is sound:
ATHLETES: HIRE COMPETENT/TUSTWORTHY COUNSEL BEFORE NEGOTIATING CONTRACTS WITH AN INSTITUTION OR COLLECTIVE!
Why you ask, consider this a non-exhaustive list of potential pitfalls, and concerns you should have:
- Compensation – Show me the $$! Compensation will need to be broad enough to cover all costs of school, NIL rights, and revenue share. Might there be a signing bonus?
- Term/Termination – Will the contract be an annual renewable, multi–year commitment with escalators (or even de-escalators), what events can give rise to a termination, and what then!
- Relinquishment of NIL Rights – Since the institution will pay for NIL, will there be restrictions on your ability to negotiate “true” private NIL deals with brands and/or restrictions on same?
- Performance Requirements – PAY TO PLAY; PLAY TO GET PAY!
- Buy-Outs – If you want to transfer can you or your new institution buy out the contract?
- Transfer Restrictions – What limits are there on your ability to enter the portal or is that option waived!
- Guarantees – is anything guaranteed?
Bonus Advice. ATHLETES: HIRE COMPETENT/TRUSTWORTHY COUNSEL BEFORE YOU ENGAGE IN ANY SIGNIFICANT NEGOTIATIONS/CONTRACTS WITH BRANDS!
Why you ask? Because here is a non-exhaustive list of potential pitfalls and concerns:
- Risk to Eligibility (Something in the contract violates NCAA /other compliance).
- Obligations/Commitments to the Brand Post College – they own you!
- Signing away and Perpetual Release of Your Intellectual Property (“NIL”) – they keep using your new-found celebrity without compensation!
- Complicated Conditions Set on Brand Payments/Fairness of any Deal.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS:
NILegally Speaking™ is written by PowerNIL/Ken Feinberg, attorney, in collaboration with other expert attorneys focused on employment, labor, contract, and intellectual property law.
ken@powernil.com www.powernil.com